Urban India: balancing growth, energy needs and solar technologies

Thane: solar water heaters in the foreground (or background?) of an intense urban growth

India’s current electricity generation is in the order of 160,000 MW. However, India’s Planning Commission considers that, in order to meet the energy needs of the country whilst maintaining a GDP growth of 8% per year, it will need to increase its electricity generation capacity by nearly six fold in the next 20 years: 950,000 MW!!

It is within this context that we need to understand India’s Solar Mission. Launched in 2009 within the framework of the National Action Plan on Climate Change, the Mission aims for the deployment of 20,000 MW of solar power by 2022 (to give some context to those of you in the UK, the Ratcliffe-on-Soar power station has a capacity of 2,000 MW, beyond the electricity consumption of Ghana). The Mission’s emphasis is on large scale grid connected solar power, solar thermal generation and solar manufacturing capabilities. When looking at the approximately current 200MW of solar energy in India today, the 20,000 MW target by 2022 sounds positively ambitious. But it dwarfs next to the additional 890,000 MW that would be required in 2032 to meet the country’s growth demands.

This is also the broad energy context that frames my current exploration of the mechanisms that Thane City, in the outskirts of Mumbai, is using to become a ‘Solar City’. Thane is one of 60 Indian cities that have subscribed to the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) program ‘India Solar Cities’. The city passed a policy that makes it mandatory for new buildings to install solar hot water systems, is implementing a ‘Solar City Cell’ to promote public awareness on solar/renewable technologies and energy efficiency, and has several pilot projects such as the installation of PVs in the roof of the Municipal Corporation. But at the same time, it is receiving large amounts of urban growth coming from Mumbai, dramatically increasing the city’s energy needs. Thane often looks like a city in construction, with several dozens of towers spiralling up the sky. These towers, their luxury apartments and shopping malls maintained by air conditioners, are for the new middle classes of India: a vivid example of the rapid changing consumption patterns of urban India.

If India’s Solar Mission dwarfs in comparison to the medium-term energy needs of the country, the Solar Cities Program itself (with its emphases on small-scale decentralized and off-grid domestic technologies) dwarfs next to the ambitious targets of the Solar Mission. However, in the context of India’s rapid urban growth, the Solar Cities Program becomes more relevant as it points out to a new ‘practice of energy production’. A practice where the citizen is involved through awareness and ownership of generation equipment. For India, the challenge is not climate change mitigation, but the energy intensity of its growing economy. But this might be only half of the puzzle. It seems that India is in urgent need to look not only at new practices of energy production, but most importantly, its ‘practices of energy consumption’. Stay tuned!

Inspiring projects in Indian cities: solar air conditioners

Scheffler parabolic dishes used to harness solar power in the city of Thane

The city of Thane, in the state of Maharashtra, recently completed the installation of the first phase of a new air conditioning system for its largest hospital. The surprising thing of this new system is that it runs on solar power!

The system aims to provide chilled air to all the operation rooms of the hospital (patient rooms are not air conditioned). Solar parabolas located in the roof of the hospital concentrate the sun rays in a ‘receiver’ linked to water pipes. The water gets so hot that it generates a steam that is then directed to a vapour absorption unit for the generation of chilled water, and in this way, cold air.

Each parabola has an area of 13.6 m2. The parabolas follow the sun through the use of both electric and manual systems, where the electric system works with small photovoltaic cells. The concentrated solar system provides and efficiency of 36% for heat energy, compared to PVs which provide an efficiency of 17% only.

Several private, academic and public organisations are behind this innovation. However, it is possible to say that the Thane Municipal Corporation has been the leader agent in its creation. A great example of energy innovation at the municipal level!

Alternative campaigning in the Cape Town municipal elections

Mandela Park Anti Vote Summit took place on Saturday with activists and community members from across the township. (Picture by Carole Guilloux)

What do communities do if politician after politician fails to deliver their election promises of new homes, electricity supply or clean water. On Saturday I joined activists in Cape Town who are articulating a new response to the crisis of service delivery in the city.

————————

It is early on Saturday morning in Khayelitsha, one of South Africa’s fastest growing townships located on the windswept and sandy Cape Flats area of Cape Town. Amongst the government constructed houses and informal settlements that make up the township the Cape Town of five star hotels and Michelin starred restaurants seems even further away than the 10 mile journey to get to this vibrant part of the city.

With municipal elections less than a week away campaigners from the main political parties, the ANC and the Democratic Alliance (DA), are out in force in their brightly coloured t-shirts handing out leaflets, waving flags and attending rallies in the hotly contested race to control one of South Africa’s largest local authorities. The City of Cape Town is currently under DA control but the margins are slim and Khayelitsha could provide a key battleground for the parties.

Like townships and rural areas across South Africa the main election concern for voters in Khayelitsha is around service delivery issues. The building of new homes to tackle the housing crisis, the connection and supply of water and electricity and a range of related issues have all become paramount concerns for the party’s strategists as voters patience evaporates.  These attempts to engage with voters around service delivery issues show how politics in South Africa is beginning to move away from older racially orientated voting patterns. This election has been described as the service delivery election with the DA presenting its record over the last few years to show how well run the city is compared to its national equivalents and the ANC hitting back with counter promises, accusations and lorry loads of leaflets.

Yet not everyone is caught up in this Saturday morning election fever. At the community hall in Mandela Park activists and community members have come together at the Anti Vote Summit in a riposte to the serial promises of service delivery that the electioneering in other parts of the township is presenting. Many have come to express their dismay at the political system that has failed to address their basic needs since the first democratic vote in 1994. With the housing waiting list in the city of 3.5 million at over 400,000, spiralling electricity costs and rising disconnections and a growing number of evictions the attendee’s feel that the politicians time has run out. Mandela Park Backyarder activist Loyiso Oanya elaborates, “Any disregard of the people’s conditions calls for necessary measures, until the dire and excruciating conditions of the people are properly addressed. As such, this anti-vote call is simply one of them we reiterate, no house, no vote”.

In South Africa where the struggle to vote took many years and many lives this refusal to vote until essential services are delivered is not necessarily a popular position to take. The groups involved in the campaign have taken criticism from many directions seeming to unite bitter election opponents in condemnation. But as another Backyarder activist, Mabhuti Matyida, explains, “As long as we live in these sub-human conditions, we shall find our own way to redemption without the help of any political party. As long as parties are part of the architects of our condition, we will not vote”

During the summit attendee’s hear from community members struggling without electricity, others in debt to banks and facing eviction and some whose homes have been demolished. The common theme seems to be a loss of faith in any party to deliver basic services and the need for people to make a statement at the election. Xola Skosana, an outspoken pastor who has received international attention after his ‘Jesus has HIV’ sermon was also at the summit and agreed with the sentiment of the activists and community members, “A vote is a vote of confidence, a no vote is a vote of no confidence in the political system”. In a few weeks the Mandela Park Backyarders will begin a new brick making project that will provide employment and cheap building materials for the area and show that politicians risk becoming nothing more than a side show for people forced to build their own futures.

Later in the afternoon in Gugulethu, another township near Khayelitsha, a gathering is hosted by political artists Gugulective and underground hip hop performers Soundz of the South. This event, including performances, debate and the launch of the book No Land! No House! No Vote: Voices from Symphony Way, further illustrates the rising tide of anger and action against both the DA led municipal government and the ANC led national government. Whilst the No Vote campaign retains a low profile amongst many voters in the city it nevertheless reflects a growing frustration at the promises of the post apartheid democratic era and the likelihood of a low voter turnout for the municipal elections in Cape Town and across South Africa.

Thanks to the Mandela Park Backyarders for the invite on Saturday.

You can find out more about them here

Energy issues in contemporary literature

 

Literature such as the book 'After Tears' can help us understand contemporary energy issues

Contemporary fiction can help us better understand the world around us and I want to draw attention to the role of literature in constructing and acting as a conduit for discourses that scholars can use to critically engage with energy issues. Service delivery is a complex arena of debate in South Africa. The post-apartheid promise of water, housing and electricity for all has not materialized despite high levels of state intervention and evidence of significant efforts. Protests centered on service delivery have become ingrained into the political cultures of South Africa’s communities with the terrain of electricity access, supply and pricing being contested from many perspectives and creating anger and resentment. This excerpt from Niq Mhlongo’s ‘After Tears’  provides an excellent snapshot of these isuess of contestation around service delivery, revealingd discourses around political disillusionment, privitisation and the relationship betwen elites and the people in early 21st century South Africa.

You can buy the book here: http://www.amazon.co.uk/After-Tears-Niq-Mhlongo/dp/0795702566

Advo or Kuzwayo is back in Soweto after leaving UCT without passing his law studies. Working out his next move, whilst remaining quiet about flunking, Advo is outside his home with his Zim(babwean) girlfriend Vee. Zero is a friend of Advo’s uncle who lives in a shack in the backyard………………

My conversation with Vee was disturbed by loud singing coming from outside. A group of people were toyi-toying along Old Potshefstroom. They were heading for the Stars Soccer Fields. Five minutes later I heard a loud knock at the door. It was Zero.

“The revolution will not be televised, Advo, Do you realise there’s no water or electricity in most of Chi, including at our house?” said Zero

“What?” I said, pinching the bridge of my nose.

I recalled that the switches were dead when I had come back from Naturena that morning. At the time I had thought it was about the usual problem with the old power station in Orlando East.

“Siriyasi, Advo, these capitalists have removed the cables. Ever since we voted for them they don’t give a fuck about us any more” Said Zero, anger registering in his face. “They claim that we are stealing electricity. To get reconnected we need to pay one thousand five hundred bucks. That’s why there’s an urgent meeting today. The residents are angy, Advo. I’ve never seen people as angry with the government.”

“Where’s the meeting?”

“At the Star Soccer Fields. We have to go there right now. The revolution will not be televised, kuzonyiwa vandag. I-government isijwayela amasimba! The government is taking us for shit! This is Msawawa, our matchbox city, and we’ll show them like we showed the apartheid government before them.”

I looked at Vee. “I won’t be long,” I said.

“No, take your time, I’ll have time to decide where to put these pictures,” she said, as I walked out of the office with Zero.

* * *

ANTI-PRIVITIZATION FORUM (APF)

SOWETO ELECTRICITY CRISIS COMMITTEE
HIV/Aids + PREPAID = 100% DEATH RATE

declared the three red banners that had been hung from the crossbar of a goal at one end of the Stars Soccer Fields. Approximately five hundred people had already gathered and there was also six or seven police vans. Zero and I mingled with the angry crowd. A woman was busy talking on a loudspeaker; she was standing on an oil drum that had been converted into a makeshift stage and placed on the penalty spot.

“We say away with the installation of prepaid meters, away”

“Away!” responded the crowd, their fists also raised in the air.

“We say that six thousand litres of free water from the government is not enough. My own family consumes that ration in just five days comrades, because there are twenty-two of us living in one house. I’m unemployed. How does the government think I will pay for water for the remainder of the month?” continued the woman.

“You’re right, comrade!” we shouted.

“We say down with the installation of prepaid electricity, down!”

“Down!” we responded.

“Water is life. comrades! We used to pay cheaper flat rates for water and electricity during apartheid. Why do we have to have this expensive  prepaid with a black ANC government? Why are we, the poor people, discriminated against by our own government?”

“Viva, comrade!”

“We must boycott the local government elections comrades because its clear now that we voted them into power for the second time their campaign was based on a set of false promises. They are only interested in exchanging the riches of this country with white people.”

“Yes, comrade” the people shouted.

“These politicians talk like angels when they need our votes, but behave like chimpanzees once they’ve got them. We can’t sit back and watch them destroy our lives by removing water and electricity. In the past we’ve fought and defeated the monster of apartheid, comrades. Amandla, comrades, amandla!”

“Amandla!”

“Now, we’re face with the monster of capitalism here in the township. It’s time for this government to deliver on their promises!

 

Blow for Renewable Energy in South Africa

Solar feed in tariff decreases will make it harder for this technology to develop in South Africa and threaten wider alternative energy generation strategies

Renewable energy advocates and supporters suffered a set back in South Africa this week as the National Energy Regulator of SA (Nersa) published its new energy feed in tariffs with a significant decrease in rates up to 2013. Using new calculations based on falling inflation debt and a stronger international exchange rate the regulators actions have called considerable turbulence in the renewable energy sector and threaten to disrupt emerging projects across the country. The 15 percent decrease in the feed in tariff rate will hit solar power with a fall from 2.09 Rand to 1.96 Rand kWh, with wind dropping from 1.25 Rand to 0.95 Rand kWh and small hydro tariffs also hit.

The establishment of the tariffs around two years ago was greeted by the renewable sector as a chance to develop alternative energy generation beyond the coal sector which dominates electricity generation in South Africa. Yet over these two years the signing of power purchasing agreements has been limited and its seems that the renewable sector has needed time to develop business plans, find funding and attract investors. This work is now in jeopardy and a period of reflection and revision will take place up to the tariff review public hearings in May with the target for a rapid increase in renewable energy generation becoming more difficult..

Local Climate Solutions for Africa Conference

Between 27th February and 3rd March the Local Climate Solutions 2011 Congress took place at the Cape Town Convention Centre hosted by ICLEI and the City of Cape Town. A declaration by over 50 African city governments aimed at the COP17 meeting in Durban later this year seeks to provide a platform for recognition for cities and towns across the continent as important actors in climate change adaption and mitigation especially around energy issues. You can read the statement and explore more about the conference here www.locs4africa.iclei.org. After four days of working at LOCS there was much to commend about the conference and I’d like to draw attention to some of comments from speakers…

The conference began with an opening speech by ICLEI Secretary General Mr Konrad Otto-Zimmerman who set out the global challenge and the role for cities by asking “Who is safeguarding the world’s climate? Just national governments?”. Former President of United Cities and Local Government, Father Smagaliso Mkhatshwa suggested that only through Africa uniting could it tackle climate change, “The African struggle of anti-colonization shows that united action works. Freedom from Apartheid was supported by brothers from across the continent. We need to carry this unity through into economic development and climate change. We have to overcome this as without unity we stand no chance. The African Union needs to be more than symbolic as we will be climate changes worst victims… This is a question of justice”. Mayor Obed Mlaba of eThekwini Municiaplity (Durban) jokingly suggested the answer to climate change action may lay with a particular course of action, “Who is refusing to do what? Maybe we should speak to our young people and see them do it like those in the North [Africa]” And finally Kumi Naidoo, Executive Director of Greenpeace International wanted to know what has happened to all the pledged money for adaption and energy infrastructure development in Africa cities; “We are not asking for charity but to pay your [global North] climate debt. Out of the $30 billion fast track money pledged at COP15 how much has been spent? Nothing”.

The work toward COP17 continues and it seems that Africa cities are coming together to present a united front for Durban in December.

 

Youth Photography Workshops in Energy (in Durham)

The workshops included photographic work around Durham and class based reflections

How do young people think about energy? This was the question asked at the first of a number of photographic workshops scheduled to take place in the UK, Ghana and South Africa.

In June 2010 the two classes of Year 6 from St Margarets school were given cameras and ask to consider, through photography, their ideas about energy in Durham and their daily lives. Some of the pupils work is captured in this book and includes their photographs, ideas and questions about energy.

The photography work was followed up by a class trying to help the pupils answer some questions, choose their favorite pictures and draw some responses. This work is part of a public engagement programme with the Durham Energy Institute.

Thanks to all the pupils. You can view the book online or download (3MB) by clicking on the image.